Rated 4,4 out of 5 by 835
Rated 5,0 out of 5,0 by duster123 Great hotel in best location
Highly recommended; affordable, 3 minutes to Penn station, long breakfast hours till 10 with good choices of food; standard room, can't ask for more ...
19. April 2015
Rated 2,0 out of 5,0 Will Not Stay Here Again
My daughter and I had a quick 2 night/ 1 & 1/2 day stay in NYC. We chose this hotel for its location close to Penn Station and a few blocks from an event we were attending. The hotel itself is fine and fairly modern. However, it is on a street that is fairly dark and lonely after dark. There was no door man and no one to hail a cab for us, so when we had to catch a cab to the airport at 5 am, we had to walk to the corner by ourselves. Some shady characters were approaching just as an available cab pulled up, thankfully. Also, the A/C unit in the room smelled like mildew. I did not report it, since we were hardly in the room. The room was very small, even for NYC - could not open the door all the way because it bumped the furniture. I've stayed in probably 1/2 dozen hotels in NYC, and this is my least favorite so far. Will not stay here again.
18. April 2015
Rated 5,0 out of 5,0 by Indernet Comfortable and safe stay in the middle of New York City
We were very happy with our stay at Holiday Inn NYC Madison Square Garden . The Room was clean. Breakfast Excellent. The location is near to attractions and transport facilities. The staff was very helpful. We will be back again.
18. April 2015