Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 564
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by SamuelK91 Big room and comfortable location
I satisfied hotel and I imagine that stay there again
February 23, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by #1daughter surprise birthday trip
The affordable cost, and convenient location, allowed me to plan a birthday trip for my mom who had never been to nyc before (we are from rochester- 7 hours away). The beds werr very comfortable. Lobby was beautiful and staff were great. The room was much bigger than I expected from a hotel in nyc. Within walking distance of many great sites including central park. A quick ride in a taxi to abc studios got us to a taping of the chew. We will be back!
February 23, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by murre278 Great staff, super location, and comfortable room
It's been a pleasure to see the effort the staff make to ensure good service -- on our most recent visit we saw one of the bellmen take the initiative to station himself at the elevators to do crowd control when a huge group arrived all at once -- what looked like a long wait was cleared up very quickly. And the staff at reception were very helpful in solving a small problem, and when we called downstairs about a problem with the TV, an engineer was at our door in what seemed like less than a minute. We had a very spacious king-bed room on the 11th floor, and were very comfortable. There are plenty of different kinds of restaurants nearby, and it's not a bad walk to almost anything in Mid-town. Good value for money, well worth a repeat visit.
February 22, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Slicer1 amazing place
I enjoyed the wonderful room and sites and they were very good with my service dog. Made me and my trip wonderful
February 19, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by SmittyUSAF We weren't looking for anything spectacular, but were surprised
We were only in New York City for one night, so we weren't looking for anything spectacular. This hotel definitely exceeded or expectations considering what we were looking for. The location was great, parking for 24 hours was a bit expensive, but Holiday Inn gave us a voucher for a discount, so that was a plus. We got a 2 double bed room, and the beds were quite comfy. The bag service was great, and let us store our bags there for the day even after we checked out. The bar area was really nice as well. Thanks for helping in the great experience Of The city.
February 17, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by amai Nice big flat screen tv ! very clean and comfortable bed , nice big rooms plus we love the free wifi
The only thing is just update the sink and bathroom paint and closet space .... the rest are great ! Staff are so helpful and great
February 14, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Kayakgirl Couldn't be Happier
This hotel was excellent, very clean, nice rooms, the staff was great, we went out for the day and they held our luggage until we could pick it up.
The staff was very pleasant and accommodating. Had a drink at the bar and the bartender was very cheery and pleasant and was willing to chat with us ladies.
We hope to stay next year again.
February 14, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Joeattheopera Opera, ballet lovers look!
Book well in advance in deepest Winter, January and February and enjoy great bargains for a stay only a 5 minute bus ride from Lincoln Center.
February 14, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by TMS96790 One of the 3 worst HI's I've ever stayed in
AWFUL, AWFUL property.
Very old building, you can hear every door slam and toilet flush on your floor as well as several floors above and below you. I spent my first night listening to the guest in the next room talking on his phone in Portugese non-stop from 2AM until dawn, I heard every word and he wasn't even shouting, he was talking in a conversational tone.
Security is terrible. No card-key locks on the elevators, so anybody can walk in off the street and get upstairs. Bad neighborhood around the hotel combined with terrible security is not a good mix.
Parking situation is atrocious. Hotel doesn't own its parking garage, and the outfit that owns the garage operates like a racket. As a result, the HI managers can't do anything about any parking-related problems, and the garage people couldn't care less. Valet parking is required, so your car cannot be locked. One morning I saw my car had been thoroughly searched overnight, every storage compartment in the car was open. When I complained. the HI management claimed no responsibility and gave me a phone number for the parking company, which does not answer its phones. My calls went straight to voicemail, never got a callback.
The only positive I saw was the hotel restaurant was pretty good for a quick bite, and reasonably priced.
February 13, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by tracyr5 Great
Great Stay and the staff was great and very informative.
February 12, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by bearcat03 Great view from the 14th floor
Only stayed one night. Worked out very well for us and we had a great view from the 14th floor. Pretty neat site to see other buildings and look down at all the activity below. Not much furniture in the room (bed, 1 chair and mini table with the chair by the window), but a bed was really all we needed. It was clean and comfortable and the staff was top notch. Short trip to the cruise pier. Enjoyed our stay.
February 11, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by DeniseP Extremely pleased with this hotel. Great stay
I am a Platinum Elite travel industry professional and was extremely pleased with my stay at your property in January. The check in was a breeze. I was recognized at Platinum Elite & given breakfast/drink vouchers and a room upgrade. Very effiencient courteous check in. Asked for a fridge at the front desk and it was instantly brought up to my room. The room was fantastic...ultra spacious, very clean and updated. Comfortable beds. Great location. Room temperature was perfect. I couldn't be happier and will be returning Feb 16 for 4 nights. Highly recommend.
February 10, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by CJSam "Renovated" room was great and a superior value in Midtown
I have stayed at this hotel numerous times over the past six or seven years, and it's always been a reasonably-priced, comfortable experience. During this last trip, though, I was upgraded to "one of our renovated rooms," which made this stay particularly enjoyable. The renovated room was comfortable (like all the rooms I've had at this hotel), but it had noticeably improved lighting, a firmer bed mattress, and some upgraded bathroom fixtures. I also liked the new and improved carpeting. It was a definite step up from a standard room; my particular room this visit was bit larger, too, I think, than a standard room.
The folks running the hotel coffee shop were consistently pleasant; the food there is solid but not particularly imaginative--but that's probably what's best in a hotel restaurant. The front desk staff were also very friendly, which hasn't always been my experience in New York City hotels.
I look forward to staying at this Holiday Inn again.
February 9, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by MEECE New York during Superbowl
Great hotel, great outstanding location, close to everything we wanted to be near, good food, great deals on food and drinks in the bar, and nice area.
February 9, 2014
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by meanchat Decent hotel that needs a facelift
Based upon previous reviews, my expectations were not that high. Therefore, I was pleasantly surprised. I was in a room in the North Tower on a high floor. The room was small and lacked a safe, but the tv worked fine and the bed was comfortable. The heating system was awfully noisy, but I was not affected by the street noise. Although the room was described as refurbished, the bathroom showed signs of wear and tear. The toilet was uncomfortably close to the metal toilet paper holder against the wall, resulting in a bruised leg. I asked for a possible upgrade to a suite as a Platinum Ambassador, but was told they did not so that although they had availability. I also was not recognized nor thanked for being elite, which is annoying when you try to stay loyal to a brand. I don't understand this inconsistency as many IHG properties upgrade when there is a problem with the room. I did not have a problem waiting for the elevators and the front desk staff were pleasant.
February 8, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Laurel NY Gift Show
We always stay at this hotel. It is on the Gift Show's bus route,clean, easy & comfortable
February 7, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Bobdh13 Not Worth the Holiday Inn Brand
Having stayed at various Holidays Inns around the world, and other comparable hotels, I highly recommend avoiding this property unless absolutely necessary (for the location).
The hotel has a good location, yet the rooms remind me of a worn-out motel, with the room being extremely dark, the A/C coming from the 90s or so, not clean windows, and light-stained carpets most likely full of dust and other bacteria. We were initially placed in a non-smoking room that reeked of cigarettes but were moved to a lower floor which was a little better, yet still very motel-ish and outdated. In room amenities were also extremely cheap and basic, more applicable to a Ibis hotel/motel.
With the abundance of other IHG properties in New York, I would full-heartedly avoid this property in favor of a Holiday Inn Express, or another property, because this hotel does not deserve the strong Holiday Inn brand name, and is in dire need of a complete refurbishment.
Further, there was no IHG platinum recognition apart from 2 complimentary breakfast vouchers, which were not for the full breakfast but for a choice between one single croissant or a muffin. No room upgrades were given despite being entitled to one due to my status, and the hotel having much availability left (i checked).
I think IHG should seriously rethink having this property in its portfolio.
February 5, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 Nice location and friendly staff
The location is great. its very close to Columbia Circle, 8 minutes walk.
The staff was friendly and helpful!
February 4, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by SGPNSW room service
Other than the following incident, we had good service from the staff.
On the first night, we called Room Service before 11:30pm (around 11:10pm) to order breakfast for the following day.
The Room Service number rang but no one picked up the phone. I then called the Reception and the Reception transferred my call to the Bar and said the Bar staff would take our orders.
The Bar staff was rude and said they do not take room service orders. They said the Room Service number should have an answering service and we would be able to leave a message with our order. But that was not true.
I then called Reception again, and the gentleman took our orders.
February 2, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by maisha66 would stay there again
the only real drawback to our experience was the outdated room. the staff were nothing but friendly and helpful, including the lounge staff. parking was incredibly convenient, and the hotel was well located to a subway stop. in the future i would try to ensure that i stay in one of their newer rooms. but, i would definitely stay there again.
January 29, 2014
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by Xxlarge Avoid if u can hotel
They do not read what customer puts as request
I requested quite room , they give one near lift
They never heard abt ambassador card
need a lot of improvements to retain and worth the holiday inn name
January 29, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Golferman1961 The Rooms are average
The rooms are average however we had terrible service. The shower did not work and took 2 days to fix it after we reported it 2 times. The phone did not work in the room and for the 4 days we stayed there we reported it everyday and no one cane to fix the phone. The carpets in the main lobby seam to be very warn down and need replacing. It was very disappoited knowing this was down town New York.
January 29, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by Dave Gen Great place for long weekend
Conveniently located, with great staff and good service, Holiday inn on the 57th street is good value. I found it so easy and relaxing to be able to walk around to restaurants nearby, walk to the central park, and even to the Times Square where I did my shopping. I´d recommend any time.
January 27, 2014
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by Dochowie With one exception
I had no problem with the hotel. Comfortable stay, gym on the premises, food was good and the vast majority of staff was pleasant and professional. The one exception was the bartender on Wednesday and Thursday evening. Each night I waited between 10 and 15 minutes to be acknowledged despite her walking back and forth by me. On Wednesday a couple who sat down 10 minutes after me were served before me despite my sitting right next to them. On Thursday, despite waving for her, she ignored me for 15 minutes. I had to ask the bar back to serve me. She was obviously too busy eating her french fries to walk down the other end of the bar.
When she finally came down, her attitude was very condescending. Probably due to my complaining to the bar back about the terrible service (Which he immediately told her). It really bothers me to when there is a 15% gratuity tacked on to every bill and the server didn't deserve a dime!! Worse hotel bartender I have ever encountered in over 30 years of business travel.
January 27, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Straight Guy Money is NOT worth
Avoid this Hotel as you might feel stsying in a second class Motel. Horrible room air condition with absolute NO control. Reported to the front desk, simply she laughed!! Took about 10-15 mintutes to come down from 12th floor to the ground floor due to bad elevator system. Took half an hour to get the car from the parking lot. I am a Platinum Member of Holiday Inn and received no appreciation during the check-in.
January 25, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by DebLaMi Excellent place to stay, only concierge service disappointed
The rooms and service were excellent; the check-in and check-out were super-fast, and everyone was very friendly. The location was very good - easy to get almost anywhere. The only disappointment was the concierge service, which seemed only able to recommend one restaurant, whether it was for breakfast, lunch or dinner. They obviously get some sort of commission from sending people there, but it would have been nice to get an honest recommendation for a local bagel place for breakfast, or pizza place for dinner.
January 25, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by TravelingDuchess Great Value for NYC
Clean hotel with courteous staff. My husband, teenage step-daughter and I stayed in a room with two double beds for a great price. The lobby bar was convenient and offered a decent selection of wine and beer-- especially nice to have an evening beverage without having to walk in the below 0 temps! Would stay here again.
January 23, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by ThomL Desk Clerk/Staff
We were traveling with another couple, the Desk Clerk was able to get us ajoining rooms. We always stay at this hotel when we come to New York. We find it not only comforable but the staff is very helpful.
January 23, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by kb88 Best Hotel to stay for a relaxed weekend in N.Y.C
We had a gr8 time in NYC, during the coldest weekend of the year...
The Hotel was a great experience!
Best value for the money, very clean, and confortable!
Nice room, comfortable bed, and good quality of soft and clean bedding!
The curtsy desk and the stuff were very proffesional and helpfull.
Definitely we would come back to this hotel!
January 19, 2014
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by hotelmotel Large Rooms, Very Dated though
The whole place could use a renovation, but I suppose the rates wouldn't be such a steal if that happened. Rooms are clean, there is a pool in the warmer months on the roof and the staff is friendly and helpful...can't ask for more for the money.
January 18, 2014