Rated 4.3 out of 5 by 541
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by JohnAus Good location for exploring Manhattan
This was our first visit to Manhattan. First thing we wanted to visit was the Intrepid Museum, so I researched hotels several months in advance. Chose this one above all others for the location. Took about an hour to get from JFK to the hotel by cab, and took a little over an hour back to JFK through transportation arranged by the hotel.
1 1/2 blocks from the Intrepid, that was a major positive. 3 1/2 blocks from 7th / Broadway and the closest subway stations, which can be a trek. After day one you realize that the bus is the best way to go in order to save your feet. Bus stop is an easy 5-10 minute walk and it will get you right to Broadway and 50th in about 10 minutes. Just check the NY MTA web site or App for the schedules so you aren't waiting at the stop too long. Getting back from Broadway area is another issue. During afternoon / evening rush hour, bus schedules are pretty meaningless. If you are lucky, you catch one. Otherwise grab a cab back to the hotel for $8-$10 (that included tip). If it was after dark, we grabbed a cab anyway. Just hold on, cause a few of the cabs we took were driven by former demolition derby drivers. They just honk and go. Get used to the honking, you will most likely hear it all over downtown 20 hours a day. Everyone honks, it can get out of control.
Also easy to catch a bus heading south if you are going to Penn Station / Madison Square Garden area. If you are going further north or south, we chose to use the subway stations at 49th and 50th street. Pretty fast way to go north to The Museum of Natural History, or south to Battery Park area.
Breakfast area of the hotel was very crowded. Even if you arrived at 6:30 AM, tables went fast. Several mornings we would just bypass the breakfast area and head out into the neighborhood. There are some reasonably priced restaurants to eat breakfast nearby, and most of the delis had grills to cook up a breakfast sandwich, or plenty of muffins, etc.
We were greeted and checked in by Michael. He was very friendly, efficient and helpful. Elevators were not bad. We stayed more than a week and rarely waited more than 5 minutes.
We were ready for a small room, but whew, it was small. Two double beds took up most of the space with one nightstand between them. We did have a nice view of the Hudson River, and could see the buildings at the southern end of Times Square.
TV was very nice with plenty of channels to view during your down time. We were on the very top floor, and the water pressure and hot water in the large shower were great. Small sink with very little counter space, but you adapt as you go. Refrigerator came in handy if you pick up some items from the local markets.
If you are a light sleeper, you will hear noise no matter where you are. Cab drivers love to honk their horns, police and fire truck sirens go right through the outer walls, and trash collection seemed to start between 3-4 AM. I ended up wearing earplugs, and that solved that issue.
Only complaint I could have, and this applies to 95% of the hotels, is they use those doors that slam when they close. You would think there would be a way to cushion that noise, cause people do return in the middle of the night and usually have no regard for people that are sleeping in other rooms.
Overall we were very pleased with the hotel. Area felt relatively safe, employees were friendly, and we encountered no problems with the room.
October 4, 2015
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by sheila rose l123456 bad service when checking in
The experience could have been handled better at check in .
October 2, 2015
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Doctor Y You Get What You Pay For
Clean room; comfortable. Very good breakfast. Good location for touring Manhattan. Poor fitness center; small, no upper body exercise equipment. Our room keys twice failed to work but the staff did not view this as a problem. It WAS a problem for us going up and down the elevator to get new room keys.
September 30, 2015